Countdown Until Obama Leaves Office

Monday, June 15, 2009

Oklahoma Trooper Interferes With Patient Care and Assaults EMT

I was astounded to catch a report of this story on Fox News this evening. Let me set this up for you. The ambulance has a sick patient in the back that they are transporting without lights and without sirens to a local hospital.

The trooper in the video is attempting to respond to a separate emergency. The trooper approaches the ambulance at a high rate of speed with only his warning lights on and rides the bumper of the ambulance. This is equivalent to being on the bumper of a semi. The ambulance is box shaped and that is why every fire truck and ambulance says stay back 100 feet, because we can't see what's going on directly behind us.

The driver of the ambulance does not see or hear the trooper behind him, which apparently works to enrage this trooper. When the driver finally realizes the trooper is behind him, he pulls over. As the trooper passes he comments rudely on the radio' "try checking your rear views," or something to that effect, and the driver responds with a gesture of surprise, which the trooper would later claim he thought was an obscene gesture.

The trooper then comes back and stops the ambulance. The paramedic, thinking that there must be some kind of medical emergency accounting for the erratic behavior and driving of the trooper, gets out and attempts to determine what the problem is and help. The paramedic explains that they have a patient and pleads with the trooper to follow them to the hospital and deal with the situation after patient care has been transferred. The trooper then tries to forcefully arrest the paramedic, who resists (as I believe he should have) because the patient is under his care. The trooper places the paramedic in a choke hold, which is against police procedure. The trooper eventually relents and the patient is transported.

Attorney Gary Jones, representing Trooper Martin, stated that Trooper Martin was within his legal authority to stop the ambulance because the ambulance was not running with its lights or sirens on. James also said the paramedic escalated the situation by challenging the trooper. While it is true that the Trooper was within his legal right to stop the ambulance, that does not excuse the fact that he did or the fact that he needlessly assaulted the paramedic and tried to force him to abandon his patient.

The trooper's only defense is that the paramedic made matters worse by getting out of the back of the ambulance. Points to ponder here...the treating paramedic is the one in charge of that ambulance. The responsibility for the patient's care and everything that happens in the course of that call falls squarely on the shoulders of that paramedic. This wasn't like a typical traffic stop where an officer would have to worry about a perp getting out of a vehicle that he was stopping. I maintain, that this course of defense for the officer is absolutely absurd.

This whole matter was instigated by an out of control police officer. I encourage you to read the paramedic's written report of the incident. I hope that this trooper loses his job. The unprofessional conduct of this officer, coupled with his inability to maintain control, his flagrant disregard for the well-being of the patient being cared for, his reckless driving, and his apparent lack of knowledge of the law concerning Paramedic's in the line of duty make him a danger to the community at large and a disgrace to his community and profession.

I'm happy to say, that in general, emergency public agencies enjoy a high level of professional courtesy both on and off duty. Very rarely does a police officer act against an EMT or Firefighter, very much like they provide the same courtesy to fellow police officers. Stories like this paint a mostly false picture of public service cooperation that distorts the professions we chose to serve in.

In the end, the D.A. opted not to prosecute either side of this scuffle. The D.A. would have been in a worse case scenario. While the officer was with in his right to stop the ambulance, he also committed a felony when he assaulted the paramedic and interfered with the medical treatment of his patient.

For more detail on this story visit KOTV's website.

Labels: ,

2 Comments:

Anonymous Emma Schneider said...

My major question with this whole incident is: while this was all taking place, who was attending to the patient...? This is unacceptable.

Also, why does the media chose only to really focus on stories that put emergency services in a bad light?? Shouldnt they be putting information about incredible rescues or responders getting out into communities and teaching children about career in emergency response and about disaster preparedness? I feel that the media totally spun this situation out of control.

I also believe this issue could have been solved in a much more appropriate way. Both parties(the trooper and the medic) should have gone to their supervisors and worked this out interagency or at a different time when there was not a patient in jeopardy. Also, if the officer was running hot to something, shouldnt he have been dealing with that instead of interfering with patient care? That is what i see from this incident. If I misinterpreted or readsomething incorrectly, please let me know.

This whole event should have never happened.

June 15, 2009  
Blogger Troy S. said...

That's my major point of the whole scenario, too. The paramedic pleaded with the officer to handle this at the hospital. He was trying to look into the best interest of his patient. He was being a good patient advocate.

With all do respect, we do hear a great deal on the news of heroic measures and dramatic rescues. This officer is a loose cannon and a tragedy waiting to happen. There were many spectators and if the news had simply brushed this under the rug, we (the public) would be crying foul for that.

The paramedic offered to deal with this in a more appropriate manner, but when you're being assaulted...contacting your supervisor doesn't seem like a very practical thing to do at that moment.

Totally agreed that this incident should never have happened. However, the crew of the ambulance acted honorably and professionally. The trooper is the one who scares me. He does not belong on the streets.

June 16, 2009  

Post a Comment

<< Home

“The most important human endeavor is the striving for morality in our actions. Our inner balance and even our very existence depends on it. Only morality in our actions can give beauty and dignity to life” - Albert Einstein